Skip to main content
Home
  • About Us
    • Firm Overview
    • Diversity Statement
  • Attorneys
  • Practice Areas
    • Product Liability Defense
    • Complex Tort Litigation
    • Insurance Coverage Litigation
    • Commercial Litigation
    • Intellectual Property
    • Real Estate
    • Alternative Dispute Resolution
    • Regulatory Compliance
    • Labor & Employment Law
    • Maritime & Transportation
    • Appellate Practice
  • Industries
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Automotive
    • Energy
    • Chemicals
    • Consumer Products
    • Construction & Bldg Products
    • Finance
    • Food & Beverage
    • Hospitality
    • Insurance
    • Pharmaceuticals & Devices
    • Professional Services
    • Manufacturing, Distribution & Retail
    • Real Estate
    • Recreation
    • Shipping & Logistics
  • News
    • Firm News
    • Wins
  • Offices
    • New York, NY
    • Purchase, NY
    • Red Bank, NJ
    • Los Angeles, CA
    • Philadelphia, PA

News

Littleton Park Joyce Ughetta & Kelly LLP Obtains Dismissal of Class Action Suit for Lack of Standing Pursuant to Article III

In a resounding victory for firm client Pep Boys, the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit upheld Judge J. Curtis Joyner of the Eastern District of Pennsylvania’s decision that appellant Vickie Thorne lacks standing to bring her class action complaint.  Vickie Thorne brought her putative class action against Pep Boys pursuant to 49 C.F.R. § 574.8, alleging it failed to provide tire registration information about tires that plaintiff, and others similarly situated, purchased from Pep Boys.  Appellant’s allegations rested solely on an alleged procedural violation of the statute.  In July 2019, Judge Joyner granted Pep Boys’ initial motion to dismiss without prejudice because appellant failed to identify an injury in fact pursuant to Spokeo, Inc. v. Robins, 136 S. Ct. 1540 (2016) and Kamal v. J. Crew Grp., Inc., 918 F.2d 102 (3d Cir. 2019), allowing plaintiff leave to amend her complaint.  Appellant filed an almost identical amended complaint, which Pep Boys’ again sought to dismiss.   This time, Judge Joyner dismissed Appellant’s action with prejudice.  Vickie Thorne appealed.

The Third Circuit agreed with Judge Joyner that a “dealer’s failure to help register a buyer’s tires … does not, by itself, create an injury in fact for purposes of Article III standing.” While the Third Circuit ultimately found that “[d]ismissal for lack of standing reflects a lack of jurisdiction, so dismissal of Thorne’s amended complaint should have been without prejudice,” the Opinion strengthens the Third Circuit’s line of decisions following Spokeo and Kamal in requiring a concrete injury in fact for Article III standing. 

The Littleton Park team was led by partners C. Scott Toomey and Kristen E. Dennison.

 

Related Attorneys

C. Scott Toomey
Kristen E. Dennison

Related Locations

Philadelphia, PA

Contact Related Attorneys

C. Scott Toomey
Kristen E. Dennison
  • New York City
  • Purchase, NY
  • Red Bank, NJ
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Philadelphia

COPYRIGHT © 2017—LITTLETON PARK JOYCE UGHETTA & KELLY LLP—ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. PRIVACY & DISCLAIMER

image description